Mary Graham

Trusty Chucks Blog

do not read this.

By 2 Comments

This week is banned book week.  Interested in what books we don’t allow children to read in schools or people to have access to in some libraries?  Check here for  top ten challenged books  (you’ll be surprised what’s on the list) or here for an ever-changing list.


I find it interesting that some of the books I teach in my classroom are on the list as well as The Hunger Games series (which I love!) and The Giver by Lois Lowry.  Write a book that makes people think or question the status quo and you can guarentee sometime, somewhere, you’ll be banned.  Way to go, freedom of speech.


In honor of banned book week, I thought I’d share a young adult book that I re-read a couple weeks ago.  This book has been so controversial that the author even brings up censorship in a question-and-answer section in the back of the newer editions. 

File:Speakbook.jpg
Speak by Laurie Halse Anderson is a book about depression. The summer before Melinda’s freshman year, she attends a party and things go horribly wrong.  And because the whole school blames her, she has no friends and no one to confide in.  And her secret is destroying her.
The book follows her through her ninth grade year and the reader gets to watch, horrifyingly, as Melinda, literally, becomes less and less of a person.  It’s heartbreaking to read. 
But that I can relate to it and see many of my students in different aspects of Melinda is why it is a book that should be allowed in schools. 
I can’t imagine the number of kids that would find themselves in this book.  Find, not only someone like them, but find help. 
That’s the power of a good book.  And not allowing students to understand and experieince that power is a shame.  No wonder kids hate reading and we’re raising a generation that has reading levels of 3rd and 4th grade when the “graduate” high school.  Good job, America, good job.
And, as a Christian, I think it’s important to note that many of the books that are banned have been spear-headed by Christian groups.  This is so frustrating. 
Maybe we wouldn’t have such large numbers of kids going off to college and renouncing their faith if we let them hear and experience different opinions and thoughts as younger kids.  And have healthy conversations with them about the things they’re reading.  And explain how it relates to what we believe. 
Keeping it away from our kids obviously isn’t working.  Let’s try something new.
Just a thought.
So in celebration of this week, read a banned book. 
When we went to the library on Tuesday, they had a display of banned books and I picked up one I’d never heard of before, The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian by Sherman Alexie that, apparently, is all over banned-book lists. 
That’s next on my reading list.

Comments

  1. Hey Mary. While I think some older kids who’ve been exposed to some of these things already would benefit from parental explanation regarding their beliefs on certain issues, I have a problem when my 5 year old brings one of the the children’s banned books home from his school library. He’s innocent. Why are the schools trying to impart certain beliefs at such an early age that are so controversial? If he can brings these books home, now I question what the librarian is reading to the class that I’m not seeing.
    Hope to connect with you soon.
    Sarah Kim

    Reply

  2. Sarah! How did you find me? I miss you. Why did we stop texting?? Also, definitely not talking about five year olds here (wait, you have a five year old now? what the what??). I’m talking middle and high school kids. I guess I’m a little out of the loop about what kindergarten is doing–we need to have dinner soon. Lots to talk about. I’ll call you this weekend.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

SHARE OUR SITE

Trusty Chucks

Popular Posts